A CSR rule that needs to go (with Nithin Kamath)
Nadh and Nithin Kamath argue that Rule 8(3) of India's Companies (CSR Policy) Rules, 2014 — which forces companies with CSR obligations above Rs 10 crore to commission independent impact assessments for Rs 1 crore+ projects — creates perverse incentives: assessments cost Rs 1-5 lakh a year per organization, reward what is easy to count over long-term systemic work, and rarely influence decisions. They propose making impact assessments voluntary best-practice guidance, with boards deciding when to commission them.
What this could change
Editorial: Zerodha's leadership — whose Rainmatter arm funds many Indian nonprofits — publicly lobbying to change a compliance rule shows how they think measurement distorts long-horizon work, the same argument Nadh makes about tech metrics.
Perspective & interests
Zerodha and its Rainmatter Foundation fund CSR and nonprofit work directly, so lighter impact-assessment compliance would reduce overhead for the organizations they back.